Unfair Advantage?

Born to Run
Frasure-the-runner saw the fruits of his labors as Frasure-the-prosthetist from up close that day: he was on the track next to Pistorius when his patient-turned-protégé thundered past him on his way to shattering the American's world record. "I should have waited until next year to make his legs," Frasure said wryly, with a wan smile.
Do high-tech prosthetic legs provide an unfair advantage to disabled athletes? I believe so. In a roundabout way, this is similar to my argument about not trampling on one group's rights to protect another's. But it's not that simple.
Ultimately the real question is not one of science but of humanity and of fairness: should Oscar be allowed to run even if he gains some measure of advantage as a sprinter from his misfortune as a human being? And how does that advantage—if there is one—compare with the good fortune of a Carl Lewis or a Michael Johnson, members of what Gailey calls "the lucky sperm club" of athletes literally built to run because of their unnaturally long legs?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Movie Quotes

Round 1 Results Congratulations! Patterson wins Round 1 handily. Stay tuned for Round 2 where the scores can really change!* Quote Character Movie Winner imtheasshole.mp3 Trent Swingers Oge wolf.mp3 Jules Pulp Fiction Patterson funny.mp3 Tommy DeVito Goodfellas Patterson nipples.mp3 Jack Byrnes Meet the Parents Patterson ugly.mp3 "Dutch" Predator Bomber brokemyheart.mp3 Michael Corleone Godfather II Patterson jobu.mp3 Pedro Cerrano Major League Oge destroy.mp3 Darth Vader Empire Strikes Back Patterson * Not really
Read more

If it's going to be that kind of party

Passed hors d'oeuvres: free Open bars: free Xbox stations: free Science Fiction Museum admission: free Amusement park rides: free Sheryl Crow plays to an audience of engineers: priceless So I'm out here in Seattle this week for SC|05 , the international supercomputing conference. Bill Gates wants to get Microsoft more involved with supercomputing, so he delivered the keynote address. Based on this admittedly small sample, I'd say Bill's parties are a lot more entertaining than his keynote speeches . The Microsoft party was hosted at the Experience Music Project , which is right next to the Space Needle . Upon arrival, I quickly located the main stage, along with the most accessible bars and appetizer spawn points. While I was waiting for the main event I entertained myself at the Science Fiction Museum , which I enjoyed more than I care to admit. At 10 pm sharp Sheryl Crow took the stage. They made an announcement that there would be no photography during the show. Of c...
Read more

Get with the program

Image
The first episode of Survivor: Panama: Exile Island aired last night. This season the gimmick is they've split the 16 contestants into four tribes to start out: older women, older men, younger women, and younger men (more on this later). After each reward challenge, the losing team has to leave one member behind to spend the night alone on Exile Island. The upside to this is that supposedly there is an immunity idol hidden on the island. Anyhoo, after five years and a dozen locations, Survivor is still your best destination for reality television. Oh I'm sure a lot of production-y stuff goes on behind the scenes, but toward the end of those 39 days, the contestants are beat-up, weathered and hungry. Some look downright emaciated. That's real. But you know what would be even more real than Survivor? Survivor in HD. Since I picked up my first HDTV last summer, I've been gratified to find more and more HD programming available. Surely Survivor would be jumping on th...
Read more